JREF
  • Home
  • Swift
  • About
    • About
    • About James Randi
    • The Million Dollar Challenge
    • Our Financials
  • Education
    • Education
    • Educational Modules
    • Educational Videos & Podcasts
    • Encyclopedia of Claims
    • E-Books
  • JREF Press

Sheriff admits psychic detective group was no help

11/22/2014

 
Picture
By Sharon Hill

Last month, I posted the tragic story of a missing little girl in Mississippi and the efforts to try to find her.  A volunteer group called "Find Me" who uses so-called psychic means to locate missing persons and help solve crimes gave police information they felt was pertinent to her location. I was highly critical of psychic detectives - anyone who values making conclusions via evidence should be. There is extremely poor evidence (usually exaggerated testimonials) that psychics help in any way to solve crimes any more skillfully than the police or private investigators. They simply do not give useful results and it can clearly be argued that there is no merit in consulting a psychic to help find a person or solve a mystery.

Myra Lewis is still missing. This week, the county sheriff held a press conference announcing that the report of GPS locations from the Find Me group did not yield any helpful information towards the case.

If only it were that easy - to tap into a secret source to find answers. It is not to be. Psychic detectives have repeatedly failed. In 2008, scientific investigator Benjamin Radford solicited the BEST psychic detective case from pseudo-skeptic podcast host Alex Tsakiris. The case of the BEST evidence disintegrated under basic scrutiny. 

It must become more widely known that consulting a psychic is a waste of time, and possible money, providing only false hope for desperate people. While there is likely a benefit to pooling resources via a volunteer group to help assess facts and leads, touting the concept of psychic powers is a dead end.

Myra has been missing since March 1st. 

Sharon Hill, P.G., EdM, is a geologist with a specialty in science and society and public outreach for science. She is the creator and editor of the unique critical thinking blog DoubtfulNews.com and researches, writes and speaks about the paranormal, monsters and natural phenomena for various publications including Skeptical Inquirer and Fortean Times. Follow her on Twitter @idoubtit.

Comments are closed.
    SWIFT is named after Jonathan Swift, the author of Gulliver's Travels. In the book, Gulliver encounters among other things a floating island inhabited by spaced-out scientists and philosophers who hardly deal with reality. Swift was among the first to launch well-designed critiques against the flummery - political, philosophical, and scientific - of his time, a tradition that we hope to maintain at The James Randi Foundation.

    Categories

    All
    Cherry Teresa
    Doubtful News
    Everett Themer
    Faith Healing
    Guest Posts
    Guy Chapman
    Harriet Hall
    James Randi
    Kenny Biddle
    Leo Igwe
    Letters
    Paranormal
    Pseudoscience
    Psychics
    Science Based Medicine
    Sharon Hill
    Skepticism
    SkepVet
    Stuart Robbins
    Superstition & Belief
    TAM 2013
    TAM 2014
    UFOs
    William London


    Archives

    March 2015
    February 2015
    January 2015
    December 2014
    November 2014
    October 2014
    September 2014
    August 2014

Picture
The James Randi Educational Foundation
E-mail | jref@randi.org

JREF Privacy Policy | Copyright © 2015 James Randi Educational Foundation. All Rights Reserved.